|
Socoder -> Off Topic -> TVShack Extradition |
|
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 02:52 | |
spinal
|
I’m very disappointed in the British government... Linkage
-=-=- Check out my excellent homepage! 
|
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 02:52 | |
JL235
|
Yes there needs to be more controls over extraditing people to the US, but if you are encouraging illegal activity on your website, then you should be responsible for that (emphasis on if you are encouraging it). This is actually one of the issues that makes shutting down sites that link to clearly illegal content, such as child pornography, difficult to stop. Often they technically don't don't host the content, but only provide the means for you to go and find it. |
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 03:54 | |
Jayenkai
|
Yeah, as bad as the extradition stuff is, you can't expect to be able to build a site like that, then cling desperately to the "I only link to it..." argument forever. If you build it for that purpose, then that's pretty much all there is to it. (he says, while downloading some telly in the background) -=-=- ''Load, Next List!''
|
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 04:22 | |
|
JL235
|
Although I would also say that the best solution is better business models and to make it easier to distribute content out to users. That is what will really kill piracy, whilst giving the producers a way of profiting from their work. We are seeing a fall in piracy, or at least a lack of growth, due to services like Steam, BBC iPlayer, GrooveShark, Spotify, and others who simply provide better systems for delivering content. |
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 06:18 | |
Afr0
|
So completely retarded. One thing is what the american court system rules (the american court system is bat fuck insane), but when the european courts are following up... this needs to stop.
-=-=- Afr0 Games Project Dollhouse on Github - Please fork!
|
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 08:17 | |
|
spinal
|
I know the site revolved around linking to copyrighted material, but what bugs me, is that if you do something in your own country that is perfectly legal, no other country should have any right to have you extradited to their own country to face charges for the same act. That's like me crossing the road without using a specifically designated crossing zone. Here in the UK, that isn't a problem, but perhaps I should get extradited to the US where I can be charged with jaywalking. |edit| Also, surely it would be better to use this site as a tool to track down the uploaders? I would have thought that someone pointing out where all these copyrighted videos are hosted, would cut out a *lot* of work that the copyright holders will now have to do themselves. -=-=- Check out my excellent homepage!
|
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 09:24 | |
|
Afr0
|
 is that if you do something in your own country that is perfectly legal, no other country should have any right to have you extradited to their own country to face charges for the same act. Obviously they do. Like I said, the american courtsystem is bat fuck insane. But whatever they rule is only valid within the US borders, so requires a court order valid in the UK in order to be valid there. Edit: Just to make it clear; A few years ago, filesharing was still legal in Sweden. Piratebay was sued in the US all the time, but it didn't have any effect because whatever decisions were passed in US courts didn't have any effects on the Swedish legal system. It was only when US politicians and companies started to threaten and bribe Swedish politicians that the founders of Piratebay ended up having to go through a trial based on something that was legal a year earlier! -=-=- Afr0 Games Project Dollhouse on Github - Please fork!
|
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 09:28 | |
|
JL235
|
Afr0 But whatever they rule is only valid within the US borders, so requires a court order valid in the UK in order to be valid there.He is being extradited. That is what the story is about. |
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 09:31 | |
|
Afr0
|
He is being extradited. Yes, but he couldn't have been without a UK court order. Just because someone makes a decision in one country doesn't automagically make it valid in another country, is what I was trying to get at. -=-=- Afr0 Games Project Dollhouse on Github - Please fork!
|
| Mon, 16 Jan 2012, 09:37 | |
|
Afr0
|
Come to think of it... if this extradition is what it takes for the UK court system to avoid being infected by the insanity laws in the US, then it might actually be a good thing!
-=-=- Afr0 Games Project Dollhouse on Github - Please fork!
|
|
|
| |||
|
| ||||